boston real estate blog   
Sponsored by Ford Realty Inc.
137 Charles Street, Boston
151 Tremont Street
boston real estate blog
| Home | Search Boston Condos | Search Boston Rentals | Buying
Real Estate
| Selling
Real Estate
| About Us | Contact Us

The collapse of the Boston real estate market (sic)

I almost choked on my Cheerios® at 3:00 AM yesterday morning, while reading an article in the New York Times entitled, “Buyers Scarce, Many Condos Are for Rent”.

Since the middle of 2006, the frenzied condominium market here and in several other big cities like Las Vegas, Miami and Boston has collapsed. Once roaring sales have slowed to a trickle, sparse inventory has mushroomed into a glut and soaring prices have flattened out and started falling.

Collapsed? Trickle? Mushrooms?

That’s news to me.

Reliable data shows a much healthier condo market, than the reporter implies, in Boston and throughout Massachusetts.

According to The Boston Globe, 12/26/2006:

Condo sales [in November 2006] fell by 10.1 percent from November 2005, but the decrease was not as steep as it had been in the previous four months, when sales dropped between 19 and 28 percent. Statewide, the median condo sale price was $269,900, a dip of 1.8 percent.

Last month, 2,222 condos were sold in the state, an amount that is less than comparable months in 2004 and 2005, but that exceeded all other November sales dating back at least to 1987.

Does that signify a collapse? Does it even hint of one? Does it sound as though sales have “trickled” to you?

I was very surprised by the article. I found the majority of it easy to believe, since it was focused mostly on the slow real estate markets in Washington DC, Miami, and Las Vegas. The glut of inventory in those cities has been well-documented.

Boston is different. (That’s actually another issue I have with the story; it keeps saying “Boston” when I think the reporter means “Greater Boston” or even “Massachusetts”. The two real estate markets are completely different. Boston is way different from the suburbs. Way.)

There were two major points to the article. One, that there is a glut of inventory in many major cities; and, two, that many condo conversions are being put on hold, and many units being turned into rentals, instead.

Which, again, was news to me.

Industry analysts also point out that rents may start sagging if too many condos are converted into apartments too quickly …

“You can do it, but it isn’t as attractive,” Tom Meagher, a Boston real estate consultant, said about converting condos into apartments. “You are not going to get enough rent to cover the cost. You might have to go back and redesign the floor plans.”

In the Boston area, Mr. Meagher is tracking 600 condo projects representing about 49,000 units in various stages, from applying for permits to active construction. While the recent slowdown is forcing developers to consider converting their projects to apartments and offices, he expects as many as a third of them will never be built at all.

Six hundred condo projects??????!!!!!!!!! It’s 1986, all over again!!!!!!!!!!

I guess if “Boston area” means from Nashua, New Hampshire to Providence, RI, then there might be 600 condo projects.

Within the city of Boston, however, there might be 30 major (more than 10 units?) projects under construction, with another 30 ready to go. I don’t know how many are winding there way through the permit process, but if I don’t know about them, then they’re pretty far off from breaking ground.

I was so flipped out by what I read that I immediately sent a note to Tom Meagher, who is an expert in the business (why else would the Times have interviewed him, right?). (No, seriously, he is an expert.) (Information about Mr. Meagher and his company, Northeast Apartment Advisors, can be found, here.)

Surprisingly, he responded, immediately (I asked him in my email if I could quote him, and he didn’t say one way or another, which is good enough for me!). (Bold emphasis, mine.)

I was very surprised. I told Vikas [the Times reporter] that developers almost never walk away from projects in the Boston area because they can take 5 to 10 years or more to do. The only reason they would is if their site control can’t be extended. Projects in the Boston area are virtually never canceled outright I told him.

We also never discussed the collapse of the Boston condo market and I agree with your point that there are two markets city and suburban. Our Boston Cambridge Condominium Report which will be out within the week, focuses only on the urban component.

I think collapse may be closer to the point in DC, he started there and probably tried to extrapolate.

There you go.

Again, I was very surprised by the Times article, because I don’t think it came off well-researched. Or, should I say, well-reported.

Complete story: Buyers Scarce, Many Condos Are for Rent – Vikas Bajaj, The New York Times

Read other posts about: Boston condo sales data

No Responses to “The collapse of the Boston real estate market (sic)” »»

  1. Comment by Larry Lyle | 01/18/07 at 1:52 pm

    John – this is very interesting. You are to be

    commended for questioning the information in the article – and going further to clarify it too.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks »»>

  1. Pingback by » Linky Goodness – 1/19/2007 | 01/19/07 at 7:32 am

    [...] Buyers scarce, many condos are for rent Saw this story

    coming a mile away. If you want a good deal on a downtown condo, take a look later this year or

    early 2008. This market won’t come back until 2010. John Keith disagrees. [...]

  2. Trackback by Gabriel | 02/13/07 at 3:29 pm


    Thanks for sharing your thoughts with us.

    Some of them are really interesting…

Leave a Reply »»

Comments may be moderated, edited or deleted; by leaving a comment, you are agreeing to the Terms of Service of this website.

Let's talk Boston real estate. The most recent real estate comments

  • christian louboutin discount shoes sale, Samuels wins right to build 30-story Back Bay complex: ...
  • James, Boston condo owners: Risk of using Airbnb: Just to be clear you’re posting a fear mongering piece, but...
  • Julieta, Affordable housing opportunity in the Fenway: Really? then point out specifically where my cmnoemts are...
  • Rene, Is the housing recovery weaker than it appears?: Give it back to the bank. If your State is a non-recourse...
  • Reyna, Daisy Buchanan’s in Back Bay facing foreclosure: Benjamin: in defense of Vangel, I think the aruemgnt can be...
  • Talene, Which direction will Boston rents go?: I have witnessed that smart real etsate agents just about everywhere...
  • Anna, Well, at least Boston isn’t Los Angeles: Your credit will tank but not as bad as a frrlceosuoe. You need...
  • Tyler Mills, Lenders go into overdrive to clear out backlog of delinquent mortgages: Instead of forcing out the...
  • Tyler Mills, Lack of housing inventory is getting ridiculous in Boston: Though inventory being down is really...
  • warren currier, ‘Boston’s faux housing boom’: Scott, Do you own any units in Boston? Supply /...
  • Nishant, Major Developers: Affordable homes can only be built outside downtown Boston: Yes, this is correct that...
  • warren currier, Done deal: Dr. Dre buys Tom and Gisele’s mansion for $40M: The property is located in LosAngeles,...
  • JS, Despite predictions, inventory of homes for sale continues to fall in Mass.: One thing that could be holding...
  • dcmhomebuyers, For 74 Beacon Street, it was the kitchen, stupid: Nice house. I think front section to location of...
  • Johnd478, Five signs you’re a ‘renter for life’: I just couldnt depart your site prior to...
  • Dionis Padron, Downtown condo prices now averaging near $1 million each: great article but prices for standalone...
  • John Ford, Charles Ponzi’s old Lexington home for sale at $3.3M: That’s a great idea. Anyone have an idea how...
  • Rich, Charles Ponzi’s old Lexington home for sale at $3.3M: Speaking of Mr. Ponzi, he ran his Ponzi scheme out of an...
  • amparo bracero, Big changes in store for Tremont Street?: I will love to comunicated my self with aida I was one of...
  • warren currier, Low mortgage rates may partly explain low inventory: The banks are making it very hard to get a loan....

  • Join us on Facebook Subscribe To FeedBurner Follow us on twitter Newsletter sign-up


    Are you considering the purchase or sale of a home in Boston?

    Contact us today to discuss ways we can help make the experience easy and stress-free.

    Search past blog entries

    Site tools

    Add To Google      Subscribe To FeedBurner

    Add To My Yahoo!

    | | | |

    Boston Real Estate/Boston Condos for Sale -
    Search MLS

    Select property type:
    Select area:
    Select property size:
    Price from:
    Price to:
    MLS #

    Boston Real Estate and Boston Condos

    Click on the links below for Boston condo neighborhood sales listings

    Boston Back Bay Condos

    Beacon Hill Condos

    Boston Charlestown Condos

    Fenway Boston Condos

    Boston South End Condos